Appeal Dismissed — Edinburgh
ENA-230-2458
Flat 21, Edinburgh, EH7 6FE
The appeal decision regarding the enforcement notice served by the City of Edinburgh Council concerns the alleged unauthorized change of use of a flat from a residential dwelling to a short-term let. The main issues addressed were whether the use constituted a breach of planning control and the reasonableness of the compliance period stipulated in the notice. The appellant, Mr. Gauthier Autrand, argued that the property remained his principal residence and that the enforcement notice was unwarranted. However, the Reporter found that the evidence presented by the council, including the property’s advertisement on platforms like Airbnb and the frequency of guest turnover, indicated a material change of use that required planning permission. The Reporter concluded that the short-term letting had become a primary use of the property, significantly differing from typical residential use and likely causing noise disturbances to neighbors. On the second issue regarding the compliance period, the appellant requested an extension from one month to twelve months due to personal health concerns and existing guest bookings. The Reporter sided with the council, stating that one month was a reasonable timeframe, considering the breach and the potential for further negative impacts on neighboring amenity. Ultimately, the appeal was dismissed, and the enforcement notice upheld, with the compliance period set at one month. The decision takes effect immediately, barring any application to the Court of Session.
.png&w=1080&q=75)